Q&A: General public school leaders seem the alarm about vouchers, Lee’s training agenda


Indication up for Chalkbeat Tennessee’s cost-free every day publication to continue to keep up with Memphis-Shelby County Educational institutions and statewide training coverage.

Tennessee condition officers ultimately produced their prolonged-delayed letter grades for colleges final month, just just before the holiday break split, applying a new components championed by Gov. Invoice Lee’s administration.

But even prior to they knew their grades, leaders of a higher-undertaking suburban Memphis faculty district denounced the method as a sham.

“This is all an attempt to paint Tennessee public universities as failing, thus ushering in a new period of vouchers for all,” a statement from Arlington Local community Educational facilities explained. It was signed by Superintendent Jeff Mayo and faculty board users, including Dale Viox, president-elect of the Tennessee University Boards Affiliation.

Meanwhile, other suburban Memphis faculty districts have begun lining up towards private-school voucher growth, far too, a further important element of Lee’s education agenda. Lee’s voucher method takes advantage of taxpayer revenue to help families fund non-public faculty tuition, and the proposed enlargement is anticipated to be a best legislative priority when the Common Assembly returns on Jan. 9.

Lee’s proposal would remove income boundaries and ultimately lengthen the software statewide. It would be a massive leap forward for a method that was when billed as a pilot undertaking and hardly survived problems in the legislature and the courts.

Viox reported the TSBA is by now instructing its customers to go official board resolutions opposing vouchers. And it’s urging university boards to advertise the strengths of their general public universities and attraction straight to lawmakers.

“I consider you are likely to uncover extra and more men and women want to discuss out about it,” Viox explained to Chalkbeat, “because there’s a great deal of folks in this region that I know individually and across the condition that care a excellent deal about community instruction and accomplishing suitable by learners.”

Mayo and Viox talked with Chalkbeat about their opposition to the voucher application, and why they feel Tennessee’s new letter grade system is part of an assault on general public faculties.

This job interview was performed on Dec. 11 just before school letter grades were being launched on Dec. 21. It has been edited for size and clarity.

What is it about the A-F letter grades and proposed voucher laws that warrants the sort of statement you created?

Mayo: The very best way that I’ve been able to describe the A-to-F grading technique is it’s kind of the appetizer to what is to arrive with the voucher system. And I consider … if the point out or the governor, or (the Tennessee Division of Schooling) — whomever is pushing for this — can paint the photograph that college districts that are thriving, high-executing, this kind of as ours, are failing, then that sets the tone for support of the voucher growth application, which, you know, eventually, will take revenue away from general public training. …

Jeff Mayo, superintendent of Arlington Community Schools, criticized Gov. Bill Lee for his proposal to expand a private-school education voucher program without plans to hold private schools to the same evaluation metrics as public schools.
Jeff Mayo, superintendent of Arlington Neighborhood Faculties, criticized Gov. Bill Lee for his proposal to broaden a private-university education voucher program with out ideas to maintain personal schools to the very same analysis metrics as public educational institutions.

We are held accountable for each penny that we get from the point out. … Each and every dime of it we have to say, ‘How is that contributing to students’ growth, or students’ achievement,’ whilst in a private college, that is not the circumstance. … They’re not held less than the same point out accountability that we are. There is no teacher evaluation accountability product that I’m conscious of. …

And so to say that it is likely to even the participating in industry is inaccurate. And which is the whole explanation we’re contacting this entire matter a sham. … I believe that expansion of this has been portion of the roadmap since day a person.

Viox: It is a poor idea to just take taxpayer money and give it to non-public entities. … We know that throughout the nation … voucher applications are just rife with misuse. … And then if you want to speak about inclusivity and range: A private college can refuse you for any rationale in any way. … So as numerous children as you might assume that you’re likely to be capable to consist of, you are going to exclude two times as lots of under this software, simply because personal educational institutions are not heading to just take them, either for their spiritual beliefs or sexual orientation or no matter what. …

You question why it’s this kind of a solid assertion. Simply because we’re in a potent placement. We have high-effectiveness pupils, we have a quite high-overall performance district, and this is almost certainly not heading to trickle down to us for a very long time. But what it does do is it has an effect on our academic companions in Shelby County. And if you assume you can just ignore about general public education in Shelby County, and just target on Arlington, Tennessee, you are improper. Because failing Shelby County schools will affect just about every one particular of these districts, and everyone in the point out. … Across the point out of Tennessee, we need to build up general public education and learning to what it can be, and not get dollars absent and give it to non-public businesses.

What do you hope the statement accomplishes?

Mayo: It’s debacle soon after debacle that we’re dealing with, with no guidance, no serious assistance from TDOE when these new mandates are handed down. … My staff members has to cease, they have to make your mind up: ‘How are we going to do this? What are we heading to do to assistance our students get on the other side of this?’ …

We retain piling on extra ineffective accountability measures to pulverize general public educational institutions.

Jeff Mayo, superintendent of Arlington Community Colleges

Even if we get an A, that doesn’t improve my stance on this. It is nevertheless, it’s a broken procedure. And as a substitute of scratching that and rebuilding it, we hold piling on more ineffective accountability steps to pulverize community universities. That’s why this assertion from my vantage level essential to be as potent as it is. … TDOE asks for enter, but we never see our input in the stop product or service of any of these new laws or mandates … . And so it’s exhausting.

Viox: At this stage, it is challenging to ignore what the condition is performing to assault community instruction. … And like he reported, they are tired. And as an advocate for general public schooling, I am as properly.

Is there any set of accountability metrics that would move you extra in favor of voucher growth?

Viox: Not me. … These men can go out and elevate cash for anything they want in any way they want. And public schools can’t do that. … (TSBA is) going to the state to attempt and say, ‘Hey, search, at least permit our PTAs and people today do lotteries, due to the fact … we simply cannot do that now.’ But non-public colleges can increase dollars even so they want. … And what we see with other voucher expansions all over the U.S. is the non-public colleges are turning all-around … and elevating their tuition for these general public university young children by that same voucher amount. So primarily, they are double dipping.

Mayo: I think it is a long array strategy to continue on to siphon cash from public schools. … It’s not unusual for the … TDOE to deliver down mandates that are unfunded, that districts are anticipated to scramble around and obtain the dollars to, you know, make it transpire. So if you are seeking at, you know, already being quite small-funded when you assess to the country, what our state funds for schooling, and then this continuation of vouchers siphoning revenue away from that, you know, which is the entire mantra driving this being a sham.

Viox: If you’re this … bent on having a voucher system, fund it separately. We would have no problem with that. And I believe if you seem at throughout the country, people today that have expanded their voucher packages, it is appear with a actually significant price tag.

Dale Viox, the president-elect of the Tennessee School Boards Association, said the organization is encouraging its members to push back against the governor's proposal to expand eligibility of private-school education vouchers.
Dale Viox, the president-elect of the Tennessee College Boards Association, explained the organization is encouraging its members to push back again towards the governor’s proposal to broaden eligibility of private-school instruction vouchers.

Can you speak to me additional about what specially that (independent funding) would appear like? … If Arlington loses any college students, you are dropping funding by a declining enrollment.

Viox: If you come to any of our educational facilities and just can’t uncover a little something you are intrigued in, in the many clubs, and university sponsored athletics, and all of the issues that we supply — just hundreds and hundreds of activities for learners. I truly feel like we would not essentially reduce students to … personal colleges. … As long as the funding is there and completely individual, that is truthfully not a worry for me. Now, that is not to say it will not be a concern for other faculty districts that are battling. … There is normally going to be private colleges. Any unique govt money to help them broaden, I would not be in favor for. …

When you seem at all these other states, I really do not know what their oversight is, but I feel Arizona in their initially calendar year prior to they expanded their voucher plan, on the area found practically a million dollars, it was above $700,000 in misappropriated money. … And hardly ever fail to remember, that if they give him a year’s value of public funding, and they live in your district, and they go to that non-public faculty, and both really do not make it or do not in fact use it for individuals (faculty) cash, they come back to us, and we are likely to teach people young children.

If the voucher enlargement had been to pass as it is been proposed … what challenges could you straight away see for Arlington’s district?

Mayo: It will not be quickly impactful to us. But as I said earlier, I imagine the growth is to continue on. I assume that is the extended-selection system. So ultimately, we could be confronted with getting rid of pupils, which impacts funding, which impacts trainer layoffs, it impacts the diminishing of packages that we’ve invested a lot of dollars in by our cash enhancement initiatives. …

I’m a long-range planner. And I feel these are things that you have to seem at.

Viox: I’m also a increased degree look at guy: If it impacts Metro Nashville, and it impacts Shelby County, then it will affect us. The best impact is likely to be on them. They are our brothers and sisters in public instruction, and we simply cannot just fully price cut how it’s heading to have an affect on them. Since as it influences Shelby County, it will trickle out into the municipalities as companies leave.

Personal educational facilities are turning all over … and boosting their tuition for those people general public faculty little ones by that exact same voucher total. So in essence, they’re double dipping.

Dale Viox, Tennessee School Boards Affiliation leader

Mayo: The A-to-F distinction that I never feel we have seriously talked a good deal about is the impression it has just on our nearby local community. For the reason that let us facial area it, Arlington is growing since of our schools. Enterprises are coming right here. Parents are transferring below, you know. And then if all they have to go by is they pull up our web-site … and they see that Arlington, very well, appears to be like like a genuinely excellent community and all the things, but their university district has an F. Which is the only piece of information and facts that mom and dad have, if they are not familiar with what’s been heading on in the state of Tennessee.

Is there something this discussion is missing?

Mayo: It seriously will take creativity away from time to time from the faculty district, due to the fact I know we’re in the process of building our 2025-26 university 12 months calendar. …One of the persons in the group claimed, ‘You know, have we at any time considered about a yr spherical college?’ … If we required to do that, how could we ever do that, if we’re having to present finding out camps and all of that as a merchandise of third grade retention? … If we wished to be ground breaking and wanted to be artistic and experiment with that, how could we do that? We couldn’t.

Laura Testino addresses Memphis-Shelby County Schools for Chalkbeat Tennessee. Get to Laura at [email protected].


Resource connection

Meet Our Successful Graduates: Learn how our courses have propelled graduates into rewarding
careers. Explore their success stories here!

Discover More About Your Future: Interested in advancing your teaching career? Explore our
IPGCE, MA, and QTS courses today!

Explore Our Courses: Ready to take the next
step in your education journey? View our
comprehensive course offerings now!

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top