A rose-tinted cure: the myth of coloured overlays and dyslexia

It is claimed that the use of coloured filters and lenses can relieve visible distortions for persons with dyslexia. These overlays are uncomplicated translucent pieces of plastic which increase color to text. But I think they should not be advisable as a treatment method or a sort of assistance for persons with dyslexia due to the fact there is a lack of convincing scientific evidence supporting their usefulness.

What difficulties me as a exploration expert in dyslexia, as very well as currently being dyslexic myself, is the proliferation and abundance of commercials and testimonies proclaiming the success of the treatment method online, such as internet sites and magazines which are manufactured by nationally recognised dyslexia targeted charities.

In truth, a 2014 survey published in the British Health care Journal discovered that 6 out of eight Uk dyslexia organisations ended up advertising these kinds of products on their websites uncritically and in an unbalanced way.

I consider that advertising the use of these coloured filters gives people with dyslexia phony hope. These who get the job done in this field must, as an alternative, be focusing on the shipping and delivery and marketing of proof-primarily based interventions, this kind of as the systematic educating of letter to sound combos (phonics), or the provision of technology supports this kind of as textual content to speech software package.

What is dyslexia?

Dyslexia is a neurological condition affecting among 7-10% of the population. It is a understanding incapacity which has an impression on a person’s ability to learn how to read and compose (in spite of enough intelligence and academic prospects).

Exploration has shown that people with dyslexia generally have trouble processing and symbolizing the unique seems of language. As a final result, somebody with dyslexia will encounter difficulties in associating printed letters with suitable speech seems, as a result producing looking through problems.

Browse extra:
A brief record of dyslexia and the job females played in having it recognised

Visual stress and colored overlays

Visible worry (also referred to as Irlen or Meares‐Irlen syndrome) is a proposed perceptual problem that outcomes in evident motion and distortion of textual content, headaches and eyestrain even though looking through, which eventually interferes with looking at means.

Documented rates of visual anxiety symptoms in the basic populace array involving 12-14%. Even so, some have described fees as substantial as 46% and 76% in populations of dyslexic and weak audience. These findings have led some researchers to theorise that visual impairments may perhaps be a result in of dyslexia.

Proponents of this theory say that recommended colored eyeglasses or plastic overlays could reduce perceived visual distortions. It is considered that the removing of this visual pressure would boost looking at and aid the development of examining abilities in the extended time period and enable individuals with dyslexia. The simplicity of the intervention has assisted it to turn out to be embedded into the apply of instructors, educational psychologists, optometrists and NHS orthoptic departments across the Uk.

But disagreement among the researchers still exists over the mechanisms and concept powering the filters’ outcomes. And debate nonetheless rages bordering the essential concern of which colour is required to achieve best outcomes.

Fantasy versus proof

Despite having been actively investigated more than the past 40 many years, visual strain nevertheless stays unrecognised by the Earth Wellness Organization’s Intercontinental Classification of Condition, the American Psychiatric Association Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Psychological Diseases, and the American Optometric Affiliation.

Outlined as 1 of the “neuromyths” of education in a current Nature Reviews report, the capacity of coloured overlays to aid the reading through of people with dyslexia has been commonly contested in just posted analysis. The current system of investigation has unsuccessful to produce large good quality proof demonstrating that an improvement in reading when a coloured overlay is applied.

For example, in a demanding double-masked design (in which neither the subject nor the experimenter realized the true analysis and recommended color) scientists from the University of Edinburgh claimed that Irlen coloured overlays experienced no quick outcome on looking at means.

The bulk of research on this matter has uncovered tiny proof of measurable consequences on studying accuracy or comprehension. For instance, the American Academy of Paediatrics uncovered little to no evidence supporting the url to visible tension in describing the examining issues of men and women with dyslexia.

And recent systematic critiques highlighted that any favourable gains in looking at could be a end result of heightened inspiration or placebo effects. This kind of consequences crop up when a person with dyslexia thinks the colored filter will improve their examining, bringing about some modifications in reading through by an maximize in consideration, energy and commitment (at the very least in the small phrase).

Folks with dyslexia suffer from visible distortions which can make looking at text pretty hard.

So why the visual distortions?

However the problem stays as to why so a lot of with dyslexia report the notion of some form of visual distortions whilst reading through. The solution for this may well arise as a consequence of their disability, not the induce. Scientific tests have shown that the perceived visual distortions may perhaps be a result of minimized engagement or attention during studying, a consequence of their difficulties in processing the textual content on the web page.

Even though the use of this unsupported intervention may well not pose an imminent harm, use of coloured lenses and filters may possibly deprive individuals impacted by dyslexia of successful interventions this sort of as specific phonics instruction, as perfectly as waste worthwhile time and resources associated with gaining a prescription for coloured lens or sheets.

Most worrying is that these straightforward colored sheets may possibly supply wrong hope in a having difficulties reader and outcome in inner thoughts of discouragement when this intervention fails to supply the promised benefits.

In this sea of misinformation, it is important for distinctive demands practitioners, academics and mom and dad to grow to be informed people. Only then will we make certain that having difficulties audience will be delivered with helpful, proof-primarily based interventions that not only strengthen the examining and mastering of individuals with dyslexia, but also their good quality of everyday living.

Need to find out more? Click Here
To find out about the courses we have on offer: Click Here
Join the Course: Click Here

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top