A Brooklyn middle university struggle flares between academics and principal


Teachers and employees at M.S. 51, a significant center university in Park Slope, filed into the health club for the duration of their lunch hour very last March to drop their paper ballots into a box to declare “yes” or “no” in a vote of no self esteem in their principal. 

A team of frustrated educators experienced compiled their complaints in a three-page, single-spaced document, charging Neal Singh with “gross mismanagement of our school” and describing extensive worries about basic safety, lack of conversation, “capricious and arbitrary choice-making,” and interference with union pursuits, in accordance to a duplicate of the document received by Chalkbeat. 

When the votes were being counted, two-thirds experienced voted in favor. The months that followed were being acrimonious, culminating in June when the United Federation of Instructors submitted a grievance that alleges a sample of harassment and intimidation of union members. Forty-1 staff members users signed on, building it the most significant so-termed union animus grievance in UFT background, union officers verified. 

The discord at M.S. 51 is a departure for a faculty that was recognized as a single of the district’s “big three” middle schools, a sought-soon after decision with a competitive application procedure and track record for challenging lecturers and an comprehensive arts plan. It was also commonly regarded as by lecturers to be a plum assignment. 

Singh took around the 1,100-seat university in August of 2020 at a tough juncture: The administration was tasked with reopening the campus in the course of the pandemic even though also adapting to educating a pupil system with a wider selection of tutorial desires following a important admissions change throughout the district in 2019. Tensions in between administration and academics have remained substantial ever due to the fact.

In accordance to numerous signatories, the grievance is anticipated to go to arbitration. Some teachers made a decision not to wait around for resolution. About a dozen have left due to the fact June, a number of academics advised Chalkbeat, which include two assistant principals and half the arts specialists, a turnover price which is really strange for the university. 

When attained by phone on Sunday, Singh declined to be interviewed and referred concerns to the department of schooling. Division spokesperson Chyann Tull wrote in an electronic mail, “At New York Metropolis Public Colleges, our first precedence is to make sure that all college students get the substantial-high-quality treatment and education that they are entitled to. The district superintendent is actively supporting the faculty local community at M.S. 51 to ensure that the atmosphere stays profitable for all.” 

Some dad and mom staunchly defended Singh, characterizing  the grievances in opposition to him as a vendetta, impressed in aspect by racism on the component of disgruntled staff members (Singh was born in Trinidad), and describing him as a beloved figure who has weathered a complicated stretch at the school.

‘An unachievable time’ for a new principal to start off

Singh was appointed performing principal at M.S. 51 right after the long-serving head of the college, Lenore DiLeo-Berner, abruptly retired just after 14 many years, a thirty day period before the new school year began. (Singh was supplied the long term post in February 2021). He experienced been an assistant principal at Brooklyn Higher College of the Arts, and ahead of that a math instructor at LaGuardia Significant University, in which he won the prestigious Sloan Award for excellence in teaching in science and arithmetic in 2012. 

“It was an extremely hard time to start,” a veteran instructor acknowledged. (All seven M.S. 51 academics we spoke with — previous and existing — questioned to continue to be anonymous for panic of reprisals or to keep away from jeopardizing grievances from the principal.) 

Learners and academics were adjusting to hybrid studying — back section of the time in the classrooms and art studios but not really again to usual. And the university was also nevertheless adjusting to a demographic shift in pupils. Final yr, more than 50 % of the school’s college students came from reduced-revenue families, up from practically a third the year right before the admissions modify, in accordance to community facts. 

Instructors told Chalkbeat that they were eager to build a great rapport with the new principal. A former English teacher stated she hoped that Singh, a particular person of shade, would be the proper chief to “help support a new discovering neighborhood that incorporated men and women of various backgrounds.”  The veteran trainer mentioned, “A great deal of employees did try to give him the reward of question as prolonged as they maybe could, mainly because folks comprehended it was an unparalleled time.”

But the goodwill did not last. 

Early on Singh produced a sequence of conclusions that appeared unwell-deemed to some mother and father and staff members, frequently undertaken devoid of consulting both, dad and mom and teachers informed Chalkbeat. He taken off the lockers so students had to have their belongings all over all day. He canceled 1st time period homeroom, which many mother and father and instructors felt  had assisted build a sense of neighborhood in a substantial college. 

In the union doc well prepared for the no-confidence vote, instructors billed that Singh did not establish obvious boundaries for the school’s out-to-lunch plan, a cherished ritual in which college students are permitted to shell out their lunch time period in the encompassing neighborhood. As well few personnel members monitored students leaving the setting up, they stated, and college students have been capable to assortment farther from the university making. Some pupils both returned late or not at all, major to confusion and nervous efforts to identify them.

These adjustments transpired amid heightening behavioral difficulties for college students. Some had endured “social and emotional damage” from the stress of the pandemic, just one trainer mentioned, and there was sure to be some fallout, even if most were being psyched to be back again at college. “Kids experienced all sorts of scars from what had transpired, but we had been not given assist to deal with that,” she stated.

Lecturers and moms and dads reported that fights had been erupting outdoors the constructing and in the hallways. Kids had been also cutting class, vaping and using tobacco pot in the bogs, pulling fireplace alarms, and bullying other students, the instructors and dad and mom explained.  The faculty issued 33 suspensions final yr, according to community knowledge. That was up from 19 in 2018-2019, the last whole faculty 12 months ahead of the pandemic. 

Incidents were being a “daily prevalence,” in accordance to Mia Total, whose son was persistently bullied, alongside with two of his feminine close friends, by the similar group of youngsters in his sixth grade year. 

Singh achieved with the parents of the little ones who had been bullied, but Total felt that the principal was “dismissive” of their concerns. She explained the mother and father of the bullies did not attend the assembly, and there were being no consequences for the children who were being tormenting her son. This past drop the bullying continued, and her son transferred to a various center faculty. 

Scholar surveys showed combined inner thoughts about faculty protection. About 72% of college students previous yr reported they felt harmless in the hallways and cafeteria. That was down 19 proportion factors from the 2019 study. But 90% reported feeling safe in their school rooms, a decline of 5 points from 2019.

Staffers railed from the principal for a host of other concerns as perfectly. According to the no-self-assurance paperwork, Singh proven new grading insurance policies without consulting college designed significant variations in the arts curriculum just times prior to the new college year and usually did not react to teachers’ e-mail.   

“The status of the faculty has been destroyed,” a veteran instructor stated. “And it is not mainly because of the college students, it is not because of the teachers. It’s due to the fact of the leadership.” 

Singh’s removal of the school’s long-serving pictures trainer in June 2021 was also a major stage of rivalry. Although the trainer was finally reassigned to a diverse arts section task, the award-successful photography system has been scaled back.

Sonia Alio, a parent of an M.S. 51 graduate, said soon after the staffing alter, college students no for a longer period uncovered to use film cameras — in its place they snap shots with their phones — and so they really don’t use the darkroom possibly.  

Some mothers and fathers called him the ‘biggest supporter and advocate of the students’

Singh has some vocal supporters amongst dad and mom at the college. In December, Tomasita Sherer, the mother of twin eighth-quality boys, wrote to the district’s superintendent, Rafael Alvarez, to express her “unequivocal assist and admiration” for Singh. “Most of the little ones, instructors and parents like Mr. Singh and would give him an A+ for his kind and stalwart management by means of the COVID disaster and outside of.” She reported she believes that complaints about Singh are “meritless.”

Yet another group of parents wrote to Alvarez final thirty day period as nicely, declaring that the principal experienced done a “remarkable” task as he took about through a incredibly hard year. Singh “has been the biggest supporter and advocate of the pupils,” these parents wrote, “insisting on respect and dignity for those youngsters who face difficulties largely unseen at the ‘pre-range-plan’ MS 51.”

The letter, whose writers declined to be interviewed by Chalkbeat, lauded Singh for promoting “excellence and equity” following the admissions variations. “After at minimum 15 many years of MS 51 currently being a ‘gifted and talented’ school that cherry-picked only the most perfectly-behaved and academically successful learners for admission, our faculty now held a various illustration of all of our small children,” the moms and dads wrote.

Moreover, past year’s father or mother surveys showed advancements in their romance with the principal, with 88% declaring they felt the principal labored really hard to make believe in with parents. That was up 6 proportion points from 2019, less than the preceding leadership.

The union animus grievance may possibly not be settled for months quite a few other grievances are also pending. Some lecturers are not waiting around for the problem to increase.

Just one instructor mentioned that she experienced developed up at M.S. 51: her mother taught there for 35 yrs, and her mother’s colleagues experienced become her “extended family” when she was a child, and is also a graduate. When she grew to become a trainer herself, she was thrilled to land a situation at her alma mater. “To say it is an institution embedded in my soul is placing it flippantly,” she wrote. 

This calendar year, following 17 yrs of educating at M.S. 51, she took a position at yet another faculty.

Tracy Tullis is a freelance journalist dependent in Brooklyn.



Supply url

Need to find out more? Click Here
To find out about the courses we have on offer: Click Here
Join the Course: Click Here
Scroll to Top